Residential Treatment vs. PHP: Choosing the Right Level of Care

Finding the right mental health support can feel overwhelming, especially when your symptoms are affecting daily life or when safety, functioning, or substance use issues are worsening. Two of the most common higher levels of care are residential treatment and partial hospitalization programs (PHPs). While both offer intensive, structured support, they differ in ways that may make one a better fit for your needs, symptoms, and the stability of your home environment. Understanding these differences can help you make a more informed choice when choosing initial treatment or the best next step for your mental health journey.

This guide breaks down both residential treatment and PHP, along with their differences, so you can determine the right path forward for yourself or someone you love.

What Is Residential Treatment?

Residential treatment is the highest level of non-hospital care for mental health and substance use disorders. You live on site 24/7, receiving round-the-clock structure, clinical support, and symptom monitoring. Programs typically combine psychotherapy, group therapy, family programming, medication management, skills training, and experiential therapies in a safe, compassionate environment designed to reduce triggers and promote healing.

Residential treatment may be recommended when:

• Symptoms are severe or disruptive
• There is a risk of self-harm or relapse
• A safe, supportive home environment is unavailable
• Previous outpatient treatment hasn’t been enough

A growing body of research highlights the value of structured, immersive treatment for people experiencing significant psychiatric symptoms. For example, a systematic review published in JAMA Psychiatry found that intensive, structured environments can significantly reduce symptom severity in depression and anxiety disorders.¹

What Is a Partial Hospitalization Program?

A partial hospitalization program (PHP) is the most intensive level of outpatient care. Clients attend treatment most of the day — typically 5 to 6 hours, 5 days per week — and return home in the evenings. PHP offers a high level of therapeutic support while allowing individuals to maintain some independence and connection to their everyday routines.

A PHP may be recommended when:

• Symptoms are moderate to severe but manageable with a daily structure
• You are stepping down from a residential or inpatient setting
• You have a stable, supportive home environment
• You need intensive therapy without 24/7 supervision

PHPs are effective for a wide range of mental health disorders. According to Tauscher-Wisniewski et al. (2022) in Current Psychiatry, PHPs are a clinically appropriate treatment option for individuals with significant mental health symptoms who do not require 24-hour inpatient care.²

Residential vs PHP: Key Differences

Although both levels of care use evidence-based therapeutic approaches, they differ in structure, intensity, and the amount of support available.

1. Level of Supervision

• Residential treatment offers 24/7 monitoring and support.
• PHP provides clinical supervision during treatment hours only.

This difference can be crucial for individuals experiencing suicidal thoughts, severe mood instability, or safety concerns. Research from the National Institutes of Health shows that continuous support and monitoring significantly reduce risk during periods of acute psychiatric instability.³

2. Environment + Daily Structure

• Residential treatment removes you from daily stressors or environments that may contribute to symptoms or relapse. Days are tightly structured with therapy, skills practice, and supportive routines.
• PHP allows you to continue living at home, integrating coping strategies into your day-to-day life outside of program hours.

The immersive environment of residential treatment can be particularly beneficial for those with co-occurring disorders such as trauma-related symptoms and substance use. When the home environment is unstable or triggering, this level of structure can create the safety needed for meaningful progress.

3. Treatment Intensity

Both residential treatment and PHP offer intensive, evidence-based care. However, residential programs also include:

• More frequent individual sessions
• Greater access to psychiatry and medication adjustments
• More hours of skills-based or experiential therapies
• Round-the-clock access to clinical staff

PHPs are highly structured but typically focus on group-based therapy, with individual and psychiatric sessions scheduled as needed.

Clinical guidelines from the American Psychiatric Association note that residential care is indicated when symptoms require continuous therapeutic engagement, while PHP is ideal when daily, multi-hour support is enough to stabilize functioning.⁴

4. Flexibility + Independence

• Residential treatment limits outside responsibilities so you can focus solely on healing.
• PHP allows you to maintain a connection with family, work, or school.

For some, practicing new coping strategies at home each evening accelerates progress. For others, external pressures may interfere with recovery, making residential treatment the more stabilizing choice.

5. Cost + Insurance Coverage

Residential treatment is generally more expensive due to housing, meals, and 24-hour staffing. PHP is more cost-effective and is often used as a step down from residential care.

Most insurance plans cover both levels of care when medically necessary, though coverage details vary. A cohort study published through PubMed found that stepped-care approaches — including transitioning from residential to PHP — can improve outcomes while reducing overall treatment costs.⁵

How to Choose Between Residential Treatment + PHP

Choosing the right level of care is deeply personal, and both can be life-changing when aligned with your needs. Here are some key considerations:

Choose residential treatment if:

• Symptoms are severe or unpredictable
• There is a risk of self-harm, relapse, or safety concerns
• Home is not a supportive place to heal
• Daily functioning is significantly impaired
• You need a break from triggers, stress, or substance use cues

Choose a partial hospitalization program if:

• You can remain safe at home
• You need intensive treatment, but not 24/7 support
• You’re stepping down from a higher level of care
• You benefit from practicing coping skills in real life
• Symptoms are moderate to severe, but manageable

Residential Treatment + PHP: A Path Toward Healing at STR Behavioral Health

When you’re navigating mental health challenges, it’s natural to feel uncertain about the best way to care for yourself. Structured, evidence-based care, regardless of the intensity or frequency, can help you stabilize, heal, and rebuild a life that feels more manageable and hopeful.

If you or someone you love is struggling, reaching out for support is a courageous and meaningful first step. With the right level of care, recovery becomes not only possible, but attainable and deeply transformative. Reach out to our dedicated admissions team today to schedule a confidential evaluation, discuss your options, and start moving toward healthier connections, stability, and support.

Lasting healing begins with that first step. Contact our admissions team today or complete the form below to learn more about our mental health treatment options. Recovery is possible — and we’re here to help you get there.

---

References

1. Cuijpers, P., et al. (2020). Psychotherapy for Depression Across Different Age Groups: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry.
2. Tauscher-Wisniewski, S., et al. “Partial Hospitalization Programs: A Practical Guide for Clinicians.” Current Psychiatry, vol. 21, no. 10, 2022, pp. 28–34.
3. National Institutes of Health. (2019). Suicide risk and prevention in acute psychiatric illness. NIH.gov.
4. American Psychiatric Association. (2022). Practice Guidelines for the Treatment of Patients With Psychiatric Disorders.
5. Brown, G. K., et al. (2018). Cost-effectiveness of stepped-care models in mental health treatment: A cohort analysis. PubMed.